🥝GuideKiwi
Free Guide

Learn When Not to Use Gift Cards and Prepaid Cards

Understanding When Gift Cards May Not Be Your Best Option Gift cards and prepaid cards can seem convenient, but they're not always the right choice for every...

GuideKiwi Editorial Team·

Understanding When Gift Cards May Not Be Your Best Option

Gift cards and prepaid cards can seem convenient, but they're not always the right choice for every situation. A 2023 survey by the National Retail Federation found that Americans left approximately $3 billion in gift card value unused. Many people purchase gift cards without thinking through whether they'll actually use them, or they forget about them until after expiration dates pass. This guide explores situations where gift cards and prepaid cards create problems rather than solutions, and offers information about alternatives worth considering.

The core issue is that gift cards lock money into one retailer or specific ecosystem. Unlike cash or regular debit cards, a gift card to a particular store means you can only spend that money there. If your needs or circumstances change, you're stuck. Someone might receive a gift card to a restaurant they no longer visit, or to a store that closes before they use it. The money essentially disappears.

Prepaid cards have different problems. These cards often charge multiple fees—activation fees, monthly maintenance fees, transaction fees, and ATM withdrawal fees. A 2022 Consumer Financial Protection Bureau study found that some prepaid cards charge up to $9.95 per month just to maintain an account, plus $1.50 to $3.00 for each ATM withdrawal. These fees can rapidly drain the card's balance, especially for people who don't have large amounts loaded onto the card to begin with.

Practical Takeaway: Before purchasing or accepting a gift card, consider whether you'll realistically use it at that specific merchant. For prepaid cards, calculate the total fees you'll pay across the time you plan to use the card—these costs might outweigh the card's benefits.

Avoiding Gift Cards When Retailers Might Close or Change Policies

Retail landscapes change quickly. Stores close locations, go out of business entirely, or shift their product offerings. If you purchase a gift card for a store that later closes, that money may become worthless. This isn't just theoretical—it happens regularly. When retailers file for bankruptcy, gift card holders often become unsecured creditors and recover little to nothing. The 2020 retail bankruptcies included major chains like Brooks Brothers, Neiman Marcus, and Stein Mart. Customers holding unused gift cards to these stores lost their money entirely.

Beyond bankruptcies, retailers change their policies in ways that make gift cards less valuable. A store might eliminate departments you wanted to shop in, increase prices significantly, or merge with another chain that doesn't honor the original gift cards. Some retailers have shifted to digital-only operations, making physical gift cards obsolete. Others have changed return policies in ways that make gift cards harder to use—for example, requiring gift card purchases be made with the same payment method for returns, which is impossible with a gift card.

Regional retailers pose particular risks. A gift card to a beloved local bookstore, coffee shop, or clothing boutique might seem safe, but small businesses close at higher rates than large corporations. According to the Small Business Administration, about 20% of small businesses fail within the first year. The longer you hold a gift card without using it, the greater the risk that the business won't exist when you try to redeem it.

Some states have laws protecting gift card holders—requiring retailers to honor cards for specified periods or refund unused balances—but these protections vary by state and don't apply uniformly across all retailers. Online retailers and digital services have fewer legal protections than brick-and-mortar stores.

Practical Takeaway: Research a retailer's financial stability and history before purchasing large gift card amounts. For smaller businesses, use gift cards sooner rather than later. Keep records of gift card numbers and balances in case you need to dispute them.

Gift Cards May Not Make Sense for Irregular or Uncertain Spending

Gift cards work best when you have predictable, regular spending at that retailer. They work poorly when your spending patterns are uncertain. For example, a gift card to a gym might seem practical, but if you're unsure whether you'll maintain an exercise routine, that card represents money spent on a service you might not use. Studies show that gym membership gift cards have some of the lowest redemption rates because people's fitness commitments change.

Similarly, gift cards to restaurants are problematic if your dining habits are irregular. You might receive a $50 gift card to a steakhouse, but if you typically eat at home and rarely dine out, that card might sit unused for years. Food prices also rise faster than many other categories—according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, restaurant prices increased 5.5% in 2023 alone. A $50 gift card from two years ago buys less today, reducing its practical value.

Clothing store gift cards present another challenge. Fashion preferences and body sizes change. A gift card received during one season might not align with your needs six months later. Stores also rotate inventory seasonally, so items available when you receive the card might be gone by the time you shop. If you're indecisive about clothing purchases, a gift card creates pressure to buy something specific rather than what you actually want.

Entertainment gift cards (movies, streaming services, games) have expiration dates and changing content libraries. A gift card to a movie theater is only useful if theatrical releases interest you. Streaming service gift cards expire after specific periods, and streaming libraries change constantly—the show or movie you planned to watch might no longer be available.

Practical Takeaway: Ask yourself: Will I spend this gift card, or will it end up in a drawer? If your answer involves "maybe" or "someday," the gift card probably isn't right for you. Cash or a regular debit card gives you better flexibility.

Prepaid Cards and High Fee Structures That Erode Value

Prepaid cards are marketed as convenient alternatives to bank accounts, but the fee structures can be substantial. Unlike traditional bank accounts at FDIC-insured institutions, prepaid cards often carry multiple overlapping charges. Understanding these fees is essential before choosing a prepaid card.

Common prepaid card fees include: monthly maintenance fees ($5–$10 per month), ATM withdrawal fees ($1.50–$3.00 per transaction), balance inquiry fees ($1–$2), customer service phone call fees ($1–$2), and inactivity fees ($1–$5 per month if the card isn't used). Some cards also charge fees for transferring money to other accounts, checking your balance online, or receiving direct deposit. A card that costs $10 per month costs $120 per year just to maintain—a substantial expense for someone with limited funds.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau found that prepaid card users, who tend to have lower incomes, often pay more in fees than they would with traditional bank accounts. For someone receiving a $500 prepaid card for work or school, fees could consume 2–4% of the balance annually just in maintenance costs, before any ATM or transaction fees. This is particularly problematic because low-income cardholders often need to withdraw cash frequently, multiplying ATM fees.

Some prepaid cards offer fee waivers if you meet certain conditions—such as maintaining a minimum balance or receiving direct deposits—but these conditions may not apply to your situation. Reading the fine print is crucial, but many people don't discover fees until they begin using the card. By then, they've already activated it and may face cancellation fees if they try to switch to another option.

Reloadable prepaid cards specifically designed for bill payments or government benefit distributions can be better options than general-purpose prepaid cards, though they still warrant careful fee comparison. Some employers, government agencies, and educational institutions negotiate lower-fee arrangements with prepaid card companies specifically for their employees or beneficiaries.

Practical Takeaway: Before accepting or purchasing a prepaid card, request or review the fee schedule in writing. Calculate total annual fees based on your expected usage. If fees exceed $50–$100 annually, explore whether a traditional bank account or credit union account might serve you better.

Tax and Budget Tracking Challenges with Gift Cards and Prepaid Cards

From a financial management perspective, gift cards and prepaid cards create tracking problems. Unlike credit card statements or bank statements, which itemize every transaction and provide documentation for tax purposes, gift cards offer limited records. If you use a gift card for business expenses or charitable donations, you may struggle to prove those expenses later.

For people who itemize deductions on taxes, charitable donations

🥝

More guides on the way

Browse our full collection of free guides on topics that matter.

Browse All Guides →